If this is a response to what I think it's a response to then I have to say that shippers who are constantly at war will see issues with everything regardless of whether it is actually offensive.
That post did not say that "thou shalt not write X+Y fic (or X+X or Y+Y) because I don't like it" or that "you are only permitted to write X+Y fic (or X+X or Y+Y) under a certain conditions that I specify as acceptable".
The post simply states the opinion of the Journal owner towards S3 Spuffy from a canon standpoint and why it doesn't work for her. The last sentence even asks for opinions on this matter from all shippers about this topic.
In case you were wondering, I do agree with the post from a canon stance but I agree with your view on fan fiction. It's open to anyone's imagination. That's why it's there.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
branchandroot
no subject
Date: 2010-03-03 04:26 pm (UTC)That post did not say that "thou shalt not write X+Y fic (or X+X or Y+Y) because I don't like it" or that "you are only permitted to write X+Y fic (or X+X or Y+Y) under a certain conditions that I specify as acceptable".
The post simply states the opinion of the Journal owner towards S3 Spuffy from a canon standpoint and why it doesn't work for her. The last sentence even asks for opinions on this matter from all shippers about this topic.
In case you were wondering, I do agree with the post from a canon stance but I agree with your view on fan fiction. It's open to anyone's imagination. That's why it's there.