When You're Not Sorry That Something Is Canceled

[shipperx]

Now, granted, I haven't watched "Luck".  It has a fine pedigree with Dustin Hoffman and David Milch, so the drama may be really well done.  However, THREE horses dying on set in the course of filming, what? 12? 14 episodes?  Yeah, the show needed to be put out to pasture.

---

From TVGuide:

HBO has run out of Luck. On Wednesday, the pay cable network, along with executive producers David Milch and Michael Mann, announced an abrupt end to the Dustin Hoffman-starring drama, following news that three horses had died during production.

Whether it was the threat of continued negative press, or that no one could guarantee another horse would not perish during the run of the series, the surprising and quick decision to pull the plug has caused many in the media to theorize as to why.

When a third horse died Tuesday during filming for the second episode of the second season, HBO quickly announced that all use of horses on the show would be suspended indefinitely. (Two other horses died last year during the filming of the first season.) But within the next 24 hours, after an investigation into safety precautions had taken place, HBO and producers decided to kill the show outright, saying that they couldn't prevent further fatalities.  

Why end things altogether? California Horse Racing Board Equine Medical Director Dr. Rick Arthur, who worked with the production when it filmed at the Santa Anita race track, told TVGuide.com on Thursday that horse fatalities are not uncommon at the race track. "Accidents do happen," Arthur said. "It's not as outrageous as it's been played to be. Any of these accidents are not unique circumstances." The third horse died, not while filming, but as she was being walked back to her stall. She reared, fell over backwards, struck her head on the ground, and the determination was made to euthanize her.

People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, however, has long been opposed to the series. After HBO canceled the series, the organization sent out its own release, claiming Luck used "old, unfit and drugged horses."

Asked about PETA's claims, a rep for the network sent the following response: "The drugs that have been referenced by PETA were administered post-injury to calm the horse and to allow the attending veterinarian to properly examine the injury." HBO, which worked closely with the American Humane Association and the CHRB, also insisted that no drugs were administered prior to filming of racing sequences for any purposes.

There may also have been future problems with shooting at Santa Anita, Luck's primary filming location. Frank Stronach, chairman of the Stronach Group, which owns Santa Anita, said Wednesday he had wanted to end the relationship with the show.

---

Game of Thrones probably has an advantage as it's fairly safe to say that no dragons, mamoths, or CGI extra-large direwolves can be harmed in filming. (Do take care of those horses, though. Please. Don't hurt the horses.  Even the CGI ones because ::shudder:: at Gregor decapitating one last season.  Yuggh!)

Comments

[beer-good-foamy.livejournal.com]

It's a shame, but it had to be done. I've watched the first couple of episodes and really liked it (DUSTIN HOFFMAN ON MY TV!), but it wasn't "I can accept that living beings died bringing me this" good.

[petzipellepingo.livejournal.com]

It seems that horses dying and being injured is pretty much par at racetracks and it's worse in steeplechase races.

It was an interesting series, a little draggy but interesting.

[next_to_normal]

Yeah, I read an article - can't remember where now, of course - that made the same point. Many horses have died doing the real thing, and there's no widespread call to ban horse racing (though maybe there should be, was the article's point). But three horses die on a TV show? CANCEL THAT SHIT.

[queenofattolia.livejournal.com]

I've read a bunch of other speculation which sounds a lot more plausible to me, as Hollywood producers are definitely NOT sentimental or squeamish about a few animals dying on location and if necessary can and will move mountains to make sure no one hears about it. It's much more likely that this was an easy, face-saving way to end a show which had terrible ratings and was extremely expensive to produce.

Honestly, I have no idea why it was produced at all. Why did they think a series about horse racing with geriatric stars was going to fly with anyone?